iLife 09

iLife ‘09 makes it easier than ever to get the most out of the photos, movies, and music on your Mac. In iPhoto ‘09, you can organize and find your photos in two new ways: Faces, based on who is in your photos, and Places, based on where they were taken. iMovie ‘09 lets you make the movie you want in the time you have. With new themes, you can give your movie a professional look in seconds. Or use the new Precision Editor to fine-tune your masterpiece. With Basic Lessons in GarageBand ‘09, you can learn to play piano and guitar. And you can compose and record your own songs with new guitar amps and stompbox effects. Illustrate your journey with photo books including new travel maps iMovie ‘09 Make movies with ease using advanced drag-and-drop editing Fine-tune your movies with the new Precision Editor Enhance your movie with dynamic themes and animated travel maps Smooth shaky clips with automatic video stabilization Add finishing touches with new titles, transitions, and effects Browse all your video in the full-screen Library Browser GarageBand ‘09 Learn to play piano and guitar at your own pace with Basic Lessons Learn to play a hit song from the artist who made it famous with Artist Lessons Re-create the sound of legendary guitar rigs with new amps and stompbox effects Jam using virtual instruments with Magic GarageBand Jam in full screen iWeb ‘09 Easily add dynamic content like RSS feeds and iSight videos using the iWeb Widget Browser Let your friends know when you update your site with Facebook notification Publish to virtually any hosting service using built-in FTP support Easily manage multiple websites and selectively publish one at a time notice iDVD ‘09 Get started quickly with Apple-designed themes featuring animated menus. Author customized DVDs with a range of options for customizing menu screens. Combine video and photos for stunning, high-quality slides
User Ratings and Reviews
2 Stars iLife 09 Be careful
I have iLife 05 on my 1.5 GHz Powerbook G4. I knew that some parts of iLife 09 would not work on my machine when I purchased it. However, I had read elsewhere that one could download previous versions that would upgrade my 05 version to the latest version that would run on my ‘antique’ machine.
Well, you can’t.
iPhoto, iDVD, iTunes work. iMovie will not install and I am not interested in Garageband.
So it is rather expensive for a limited upgrade. Apple Support suggest I could purchase iLife 08 or upgrade my machine (one cannot upgrade Powerbooks)
Looks like Apple is taking a page out of Microsoft’s book.
Sign of the times I guess.
1 Star No Excuse!
I’m a positive person, so here’s the good news first:
GarageBand has a cool new interface.
iWeb has cool new widgets.
THE BAD
iMovie is still a travesty. Audio editing is impossible. Audio importing and placement is impossible. Clip editing is impossible. I realize I am overusing the word impossible in this review, but iMovie ‘09 is simply impossible. Totally non-intuitive and frustrating. My wrist was aching after only 15 minutes of trying to manipulate the editing controls. Also, it keeps crashing on my MacPro. In my book, there is no reason an Apple native app should crash so often on any Mac. Playback is stuttery and any editing I have tried to do just brings up the spinning beach ball of death. Avoid iMovie ‘09 like the plague and just go download ‘06 again. Whoever designed the new iMovie needs a spanking.
Also, when I fired up iPhoto ‘09 the first time after installing, it said my library needed to be upgraded. Then it proceeded to tell me that my photos had been upgraded with a newer version of iPhoto, and that I needed to install the latest version of iPhoto in order to access my library, then it shut down…um…I just installed the latest version of iPhoto. To fix this, I had to re-import all my photos from scratch. None of my albums were preserved, so now I’ve once again got 15,000 random, uncatalogued photos that I was accessing just fine before I installed iPhoto ‘09.
Avoid iLife ‘09 unless you like pain, misery, confusion and frustration.
2 Stars Not worth the $79. Problems applenty…
I’ve been a mac user for two years now and couldn’t be happier with my macbook pro, mac mini, ipod touch, and shuffle.
iLife was a huge letdown.
First the good:
I like the iWeb and Garage band apps. They work as advertised (so far).
iWeb seems to be more intuitive and easier to work with. I just gave Garage band a cursory look (I’m not a big GB user) and it seems to work fine. Nice addition of the lessons, I might actually use this piece.
Now the bad:
iPhoto face recognition does not work. Period. I had to go through ALL of my photos to correct or add names to every single face. Zero recognition.
iMovie was a disaster. Completely corrupted my current video of my wife’s baby shower. It caused the video to play in gray scale and static. Not sure what that’s about. I will have to start all over with the video capture to see if it fixes it.
All in all, a waste of money and complete disappointment.
Updates had better be on the way because this is horrible!
4 Stars The value of iLife varies depending on your needs
I’m happy with the new iLife. The improvements to iPhoto and iMovie are both very welcome. The lessons feature of Garage Band might be something I might use. The additions to iWeb are good but the program still is only useful for a personal site. It just doesn’t offer the search engine optimization capabilities or speed of loading that a business site needs in today’s web environment. iDVD has some expanded features and new themes but isn’t a have-to-have update.
I’ll cover iPhoto first. The new face recognition ability is awesome and amazingly good. I never bothered to make smart albums of individuals before. I went through several thousand photos in a few hours and did that with ease. That one feature makes almost the purchase price worth it all by itself. Geotagging is great. I gave my recent vacation photos location tags and will continue to do so. I’m researching a handheld GPS to sync with my camera so I automate the process. As the number of geotagged photos grows, especially my bird and travel shots. This could turn into a terrific feature. And the tags translate to Flickr maps.
The new built in sharing features in iPhoto are also nice. I can upload to Flickr without exporting and using Flickr’s flaky software, or without having to buy a third party plugin. iPhoto also works with Facebook. There are existing free upload plugins for other services like Picasa and Shutterbug that should work.
iMovie has gotten back some of the functionality it lost in the 08 “upgrade”, not all of it and you still can’t use the old third party plugins I bought prior to that, but it is better. The anti-shake function actually does a pretty good job of smoothing out hand held clips. And being able to edit audio directly in the program is very nice. It’s a good but not spectacular move up from the last version.
I use Garage Band, too. The new features are limited here. There are some nice interface tweaks. Those don’t add much in the way of functionality, but it looks nice. For guitar players, Garage Band has some added effects.
The ability to buy lessons might prove to be a good feature. That will depend on what lessons become available. Right now Apple seems more interested in getting big names for the lessons than great teachers. Whether or not the lesson library becomes worthwhile will be something I’ll watch. I certainly wouldn’t buy iLife for the GB upgrade.
4 Stars Nice upgrade, but face recognition is quite weak
I bought the iLife ‘09 upgrade with great expectations for the
face recognition feature in Iphoto. Such feature can really help
to bring some structure in a huge pile of pictures that I was too
lazy to organize manually.
So, does face recognition work? Well, only about 60% of the time. Its quite a bit
weaker than Google’s Picasa face recognition.
Like a psychic running amok, Iphoto sees faces in trees and in other
mysterious spots. More irritating is that it completely misses some
30% of obvious faces in typical photos. Its hard to understand why.
Once faces are detected, the process of tying them to people is
generally OK. It makes suggestions of snapshots that might
match the given person. The more faces it knows of a person,
the better IPhoto gets, but it runs out of steam soon. This process
leaves a good portion of the faces undetermined. To get those
remaining faces properly named you have to manually flip
through thousands of pictures.
In summary, faces in Iphoto works, but is not up to the
general apple standard. Its quite a bit weaker than
the similar feature in Google’s Picasa.
Another missed opportunity is its non-existent interface
to Apple’s address book.
Instead, you are making a totally separate people database with just
the name, full name and email of a person.
For a company that made all tools work so seamlessly together,
this is an unexplicable miss. A few smaller bugs in the naming in
the pop-up menus show that the new features were added
quite sloppily.
On the positive side, the ‘places’ tool is quite nice. Any picture
that I took with the iphone magically showed up on the correct
spot in the map. Adding locations to non-geotagged pictures is
quite easy and flexible. An hour of work results in a nice virtual
map with pins all over the world you’ve traveled.
Overall, this is a useful upgrade with some disappointing
misses.
Buy/More Info